Reactions of Alkenes with Hydrogen Halides
A concise revision guide to the addition reaction of alkenes with hydrogen halides, including HBr and HCl, the electrophilic addition mechanism, carbocation formation and why one product may form in greater amount with unsymmetrical alkenes.
- 3.3.4.2i-a
- 3.3.4.2iii-a
- 3.3.4.2iv-a
- 3.3.4.2iv-b
- 3.3.4.2iv-c
- 3.3.4.2iv-d
What these spec points say
- 3.3.4.2i-a know the electrophilic addition reaction of alkenes with HBr
- 3.3.4.2iii-a outline the electrophilic addition mechanism for reactions of alkenes with HBr
- 3.3.4.2iv-a explain the formation of major and minor products in addition reactions of unsymmetrical alkenes
- 3.3.4.2iv-b explain the formation of products in addition reactions of unsymmetrical alkenes by reference to the relative stability of primary carbocation intermediates
- 3.3.4.2iv-c explain the formation of products in addition reactions of unsymmetrical alkenes by reference to the relative stability of secondary carbocation intermediates
- 3.3.4.2iv-d explain the formation of products in addition reactions of unsymmetrical alkenes by reference to the relative stability of tertiary carbocation intermediates
HBr and Propene: Major and Minor Products
Choose a step to watch HBr add to propene by two routes, compare the two carbocations and see why 2-bromopropane is the major product.
© Dr. Mohammed Al-Fatah – onlinelearningsystem.net
Before You Start
This page builds on GCSE work on covalent bonding, acids and the addition reactions of alkenes.
- A covalent bond is a shared pair of electrons between two atoms.
- Acids release hydrogen ions, H+, in solution; hydrogen bromide and hydrogen chloride dissolve in water to form acids.
- Alkenes undergo addition reactions: atoms add across the C=C double bond to give one product.
GCSE Recap: Covalent Molecules and Acids
Four quick GCSE questions on covalent bonds, acids and addition before you meet the hydrogen halides.
The Overall Reaction
Alkenes react with hydrogen halides such as hydrogen bromide, HBr, or hydrogen chloride, HCl, in an addition reaction.
The C=C double bond opens. The hydrogen atom adds to one carbon atom from the original double bond, and the halogen atom adds to the other carbon atom.
The functional group changes from an alkene to a halogenoalkane.
Key idea: This is addition because two atoms are added across the C=C double bond and the alkene becomes a saturated halogenoalkane.
Quick Check: Formula and Reaction Type
Work out the product of an addition that this page does not show.
Why HBr and HCl Act as Electrophiles
In hydrogen bromide, bromine is more electronegative than hydrogen. This means the H-Br bond is polar, with an uneven distribution of electron density.
The hydrogen atom carries a partial positive charge, Hδ+, while the bromine atom carries a partial negative charge, Brδ–.
The C=C double bond (the π bond) is a centre of high electron density and attracts the electrophile, Hδ+. The hydrogen atom is the electrophile because it accepts a pair of electrons from the double bond.
Electrophile: An electron-pair acceptor. In this reaction, Hδ+ is attracted to the C=C double bond, a centre of high electron density, and begins the electrophilic addition mechanism.
Exam focus: The electrophile is the Hδ+ atom of HBr, not Br–. The C=C double bond attacks the hydrogen atom first.
Bromine pulls the bonding pair towards itself, so the Hδ+ end of H–Br is attracted to the C=C double bond and acts as the electrophile.
Quick Check: Which End Attacks?
Decide whether the statement about hydrogen iodide is true or false.
Watch: one alkene, two different products
But-1-ene and HBr give two different products. Both form, but one forms far more. Which one, and why?
The Electrophilic Addition Mechanism
The C=C double bond donates a pair of electrons to Hδ+, forming a new C-H bond. At the same time, the H-Br bond breaks by heterolytic fission, producing Br–.
After H+ has added, one carbon atom from the original C=C double bond becomes positively charged. This produces a carbocation intermediate.
The bromide ion, Br–, then donates a lone pair to the carbocation, forming the final bromoalkane product.
Step 1: The C=C double bond attacks Hδ+
The C=C double bond is a centre of high electron density, so it is attracted to the partially positive hydrogen atom in HBr.
Step 2: H-Br breaks heterolytically
Both electrons from the H-Br bond move to bromine, forming Br– and leaving a carbocation on the organic molecule.
Step 3: Br– attacks the carbocation
The bromide ion donates a lone pair to the positively charged carbon, forming a new C-Br bond.
The C=C double bond reacts with Hδ+ first, then Br- attacks the carbocation intermediate to form the halogenoalkane.
Quick Check: Run the Mechanism
Follow hydrogen iodide and oct-4-ene through the mechanism, one step at a time.
Unsymmetrical Alkenes Can Form More Than One Product
When an alkene is unsymmetrical, HBr or HCl can add in two different ways. This is because H+ can add to either carbon atom of the C=C double bond.
Each possible route forms a different carbocation intermediate. These carbocations can have different stabilities, so the products are not always formed in equal amounts.
Route 1
H+ adds to one carbon atom of the C=C bond, forming one possible carbocation intermediate.
Route 2
H+ adds to the other carbon atom of the C=C bond, forming a different carbocation intermediate.
Key idea: The major product usually forms from the pathway that produces the more stable carbocation intermediate.
Quick Check: Compare the Two Routes
Drag the words and numbers into place to compare the two carbocations.
Why One Product Forms in Greater Amount
A carbocation is an organic ion with a positively charged carbon atom. Carbocations are stabilised when alkyl groups are attached to the positively charged carbon.
Alkyl groups are electron-releasing. They help spread out and reduce the positive charge, making the carbocation less reactive and more stable.
Because the more stable carbocation is formed more readily, the reaction proceeds mainly through that pathway. This leads to a higher yield of the corresponding product.
| Carbocation type | Alkyl groups attached to C+ | Relative stability |
|---|---|---|
| Primary | One alkyl group | Less stable |
| Secondary | Two alkyl groups | More stable |
| Tertiary | Three alkyl groups | Most stable |
Exam focus: Explain the major product by comparing carbocation stability, not just by stating which product forms.
Alkyl groups stabilise carbocations by releasing electron density towards the positively charged carbon.
The major product comes from the more stable carbocation: the one with more alkyl groups attached to the positive carbon.
Quick Check: Explain the Major Product
Write a short explanation, then compare it with the mark points and the model answer.
Major and Minor Products: The AQA Wording
AQA describes the two products from an unsymmetrical alkene as the major product and the minor product, and asks you to explain their formation by reference to the relative stabilities of primary, secondary and tertiary carbocation intermediates.
With propene and HBr, adding H+ to the end carbon gives a secondary carbocation, while adding it to the middle carbon gives a primary carbocation.
The secondary carbocation is more stable, so 2-bromopropane is the major product and 1-bromopropane is the minor product.
How to write the explanation
- Draw both carbocations and label each as primary, secondary or tertiary.
- State that alkyl groups are electron-releasing and push electron density towards the positive carbon, reducing and stabilising the charge.
- State that the more alkyl groups attached to C+, the more stable the carbocation: tertiary is more stable than secondary, which is more stable than primary.
- Conclude that the major product forms through the more stable carbocation.
Exam focus: A mark is often given for saying the secondary carbocation is more stable than the primary carbocation, and another for linking the major product to it. Naming the products alone does not earn the explanation marks.
Quick Check: Pick the Accurate Statement
In each round, choose the one statement that is accurate.
FAQs
These questions secure the electrophile and major-product reasoning that HX questions reward.
Why does the hydrogen atom, not the bromine atom, react with the C=C double bond first?
Bromine is more electronegative than hydrogen, so H-Br is polar with Hδ+. The C=C double bond, a centre of high electron density, is attracted to Hδ+ and donates an electron pair to it. Br– only attacks once the carbocation has formed.
Does but-2-ene give a major and a minor product with HBr?
No. But-2-ene is symmetrical, so adding H+ to either carbon of the C=C bond gives the same secondary carbocation. Only one product forms: 2-bromobutane.
Why is a tertiary carbocation more stable than a primary one?
A tertiary carbocation has three alkyl groups on the positive carbon, and each releases electron density towards it. This spreads out and reduces the positive charge more than the single alkyl group of a primary carbocation.
Is the minor product formed at all?
Yes, in a small amount. The less stable carbocation still forms some of the time, so a mixture results. For an unsymmetrical alkene, name both the major and the minor product.
Does HCl add to alkenes in the same way as HBr?
Yes. H-Cl is polar with Hδ+, so it adds by the same electrophilic addition mechanism through a carbocation. Ethene and HCl give chloroethane, a halogenoalkane.
Copyright notice: This OLS revision content, including the explanations, layout, diagrams, tables and embedded learning structure, is authored for Online Learning System by Dr. Mohammed Al-Fatah. It may not be copied, reproduced, redistributed or adapted without written permission.
Keep this note — free
Save your progress across every AQA topic. A free account remembers which topics you have covered, saves your question scores, and syncs across your phone and laptop.
- Track every topic you have finished
- Keep your practice-question scores
- No payment, no card, free forever
Already registered? Log in